My answer to my daughter’s concern that immigrants have more hope in America than born Americans.
My daughter made a statement that surprised all the immigrants at Christmas dinner in our home. Here is my answer to her statement that immigrants are too hopeful about America.
Your support for Independent Media is essential!
We are grateful for our Paid Subscribers and Free Subscribers. Misinformation funded by the deep pockets of our Oligarchy floods the internet. We are using all our platforms on-air, online, and in publications to counter that. Please invest the equivalent of less than a coffee to ensure we can keep doing this effectively. You get premium content, our books, & more!
Jan 6 was a terrorist coup attempt.
Summary
The narrator reflects on a profound question posed by his daughter during a Christmas dinner: why do immigrants often have more hope in America than native-born citizens? He explores generational differences, the impact of systemic failures, and the resilience of immigrants, ultimately emphasizing the need for action over hope. Despite challenges, he calls for a collective fight to reclaim America from inequality and corporate greed.
Key Points
Immigrant Optimism: Immigrants at the table display hope rooted in their experiences of overcoming challenges and seeing America as a land of opportunity.
Generational Disillusionment: The narrator’s daughter, shaped by years of witnessing America’s decline, questions the optimism of immigrants.
Systemic Failures: Economic inequality, eroded labor protections, and political dysfunction have fueled native-born Americans’ cynicism.
Action Over Hope: The narrator stresses that change requires active resistance, not passive optimism.
A Progressive Call to Action: He urges people to resist systemic oppression and fight for a just, equitable America despite current political challenges.
Progressive Slant Summary
The narrator’s reflections highlight a truth central to progressive values: Hope alone won’t rebuild America—it requires action, solidarity, and the courage to confront systemic inequities. Immigrants’ resilience serves as a beacon of possibility. Still, the burden now falls on all generations to create an America where opportunity and justice are realities for everyone, not just aspirations.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Egberto Off The Record to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.